Follow the money

Investors and corporations want to make big profits off MOOCs. Where do the needs of students fit in the picture?

In much of the public commentary about technology, innovation and disruption in higher education, online education is touted for its promise to dramatically increase access. To be sure, broad access to high-quality higher education is a valuable goal that should inform higher education policy in any democratic society. However, in many ways, access is not the primary goal of those promoting online higher education.

Increasingly, online higher education is big business with huge profits being made by many private companies. None other than Rupert Murdoch, for instance, has opined that education in the United States represents a potential investment opportunity of $500 billion.

“Ed tech” is itself a huge sub-area in the “education industry.” According to GVS Advisors, an ed tech consulting group, investment in that sector hit $1.1 billion in 2012, a figure almost as big as that in the dot-com market. Profits are following for many investors in this market area. For instance, in just one year (from the second quarter of 2011 to the second quarter of 2012), investors in 324 companies offering ed tech products and services made $1.43 billion.

For-profits: A cautionary model

Online higher education has also become a hot spot for corporate growth. During the first part of the 2000s, stand-alone for-profit entities, such as the University of Phoenix and Kaplan University, were the leaders in the online higher education business world. And they were hugely successful. During that time, five of the top 25 growth companies in the country were education entities heavily involved in online education. In fact, reported Slate’s Anya Kamenetz, between 2000 and 2003, online higher education providers were the darlings of Wall Street and the highest-earning stocks of any industry.

Later in the decade, however, the American public learned why the profits were so huge. After a series of scandals about fraudulent practices, shoddy degrees, dismal graduation rates and a host of other issues, the U.S. Senate Health, Education, Labor and Pensions Committee, under the leadership of Sen. Tom Harkin (D-Iowa), investigated. Its report, “For Profit Higher Education: The Failure to Safeguard the Federal Investment and Ensure Student Success,” revealed that these for-profit providers spent more on advertising and recruitment than on instruction. Profits in 2009 alone were more than $3 billion, with a whopping profit margin of 19.4 percent, the committee found.

These profits primarily came from federal financial aid dollars (and still do), courtesy of the American taxpayer. As the Harkin report detailed, the amount of public money involved is enormous. In 2011 alone, $32 billion in federal financial aid—25 percent of all Department of Education financial aid funds— was funneled to for-profit colleges. Pell Grant money going to these companies grew from $1.1 billion in 2000-2001 to $7.5 billion in 2009-2010, twice as fast as the overall increase in the program. In just four years, from 2006 to 2010, veterans’ educational benefits flowing to for-profits increased 683 percent.

MOOCS enter the picture

The latest for-profit online innovation, massive open online courses, known as MOOCs, seems poised to make a big revenue leap as well. Despite having no significant profits at this point and a product that is being given away for the most part, investors seem confident that profits are in their future and are prepared to put up the money necessary to explore the possibilities. The three big MOOC providers, Coursera, Udacity and edX have “cash to burn,” according to anInside Higher Ed article, “How Will MOOCs Make Money?” by Steve Kolowich: Udacity has received at least $21.5 million of investor money and Coursera, $43 million. EdX, while technically a nonprofit, has been generously bankrolled with $60 million from MIT and Harvard.

The rationale presented to the public for this latest online learning innovation is high-minded and even utopian. With no acknowledgment of the dismal completion rates for MOOCs or the digital divide impediments to online learning even in the United States, MOOC promoters promise unimagined-before access to higher education and the dawning of a new age.

For instance, Daphne Koller, CEO for Coursera, writes in “How Online Education Can Create a ‘Global Classroom’ ” that MOOCs can erase “barriers between people of different cultures,” give students a chance to learn “without the limits imposed by physical or socio-economic circumstances,” and offer teachers everywhere “the ability to transcend boundaries.” Sebastian Thrun, head of Udacity, sees MOOCs as “the beginning of something magical” and somewhat more prosaically predicts “a tenfold increase in the market for higher education,” reports Don Clark in the Wall Street Journal.

Yet, for parents, students and the general public who focus primarily on what education means for people’s futures, for social mobility, a healthy economy and a robust democracy, a dip into the insider talk of MOOCs, their investors and industry analysts is both instructive and disorienting.

What online-industry insiders say

The burning questions in the for-profit education industry focus squarely and exclusively on what will make money for particular companies. Will Pearson be able to make massive textbook sales off of its involvement in MOOCs? Will charging successful students for placement services work as a viable profit-generator for MOOCs? What price will the market bear for MOOC student certificates of completion? MOOC companies are even exploring the possibility of making money by referring students, if they fail in their courses, to traditional colleges and universities where they might do better.

In the insider talk, Udacity and Coursera are not judged by the quality of the actual educational experiences they provide students, the degree to which they tear down barriers for students and instructors around the globe, or any of the goals so passionately discussed in public. The bottom line is business—which company looks positioned to make the most money, as George Siemens writes in “Quality Control in MOOCs” on the xEd Book blog. In the cases of Udacity and Coursera, it seems a tough race to call because “Udacity has a better range of monetization strategies—content, teaching, platform, recognition,” while “Coursera as a brand will rely heavily on their [highly respected, elite] university partners.”

Even Moody’s is in the mix with angles few industry outsiders would predict. Moody’s has projected, for instance, that MOOCs will be good credit news for elite institutions by allowing them “to use their powerful brand reputations to get ahead of rapid technological changes that could destabilize their residential business models over the long-run.” By offering MOOCs, elite institutions will further “benefit from favorable publicity, in the form of enhanced name recognition and political good will.” In fact, the biggest bottom line benefit for them has nothing to do with education: “The most significant short-term benefit to the top-tier universities is blunting public criticism that wealthy universities do not provide enough service to fulfill their public mission and, therefore, maintain their tax-exempt status in the United States.”

In ways outsiders rarely ponder, industry analysts are also blunt about how larger political and social factors affect markets and profits. Insiders are keenly aware, for instance, that keeping tuition up and public funding down is not the horror for them that it is for American families. In fact, as finance analyst Gregg Bayes-Brown makes clear, that situation helps online companies expand their markets and increase their profits:

“As costs continue to mount in higher education, online courses will undoubtedly appeal to cash-strapped students looking to dodge a lifetime of debt. Furthermore, as governments continue to scrabble for money in the on-going financial stalemate, other forms of income may dry up, leading to some universities running out of gas.”

Whatever one’s feelings about whether private companies are a plus or a minus in higher education, broader access to the full range of facts about corporate interests is a fundamental requirement for a discussion that leads to sound higher education policy.

Only when the public also “follows the money” in online higher education will we be able to make the best decisions about the future of higher education in our country.

The Campaign for the Future of Higher Education

This article is an adaptation of “The ‘Promises’ of Online Higher Education: Profits,” the first of three working papers issued this fall by the Campaign for the Future of Higher Education. CFHE is an organization of campus-based and national faculty and staff organizations, of which the AFT is a member. It came together in 2011 to fight for access, affordability and funding in higher education, and to ensure that the voices of faculty, staff, students and families are heard when administrators and policymakers talk about “education reform.” To read this paper in its entirety, go to

Susan Meisenhelder is professor emeritus of English at California State University, San Bernardino, and former president of the California Faculty Association, which represents the 23,000 faculty who teach on the 23 campuses of the California State University. For the last several years, she has been working with the Campaign for the Future of Higher Education.

Learn Some Quick And Helpful Tips For Hobbies

There are different types of hobbies available. It’s a good idea to take time out from the hectic world to have fun occasionally.

Reading is a truly valuable hobby that is well loved by many. Reading can take you away to other times and places. You can also ready nearly anywhere that it is quiet. There are so many different types of books out there to enjoy.

Try to go fishing if you are looking for a relaxing hobby. All that you have to find a place to fish and fishing supplies. Make sure you can fish in the area you’ve chosen. Fishing is a great way to wind down from the day.

Chat with others who enjoy the same hobbies that you have. Not everyone will appreciate the same interests as you. Join online as well as offline groups to meet people who have the same interests.

Hiking is a great hobby that gets you out in shape while enjoying nature. Look for local hiking trails and start basking in nature. Take a friend along and have a nice, and maybe even take a picnic basket along with you and then hike to your favorite spot to sit down and enjoy that picnic lunch.

Turn your love of football into a hobby. You don’t need to play fantasy football as a hobby. Get friends together and make a draft.

If you would like to use your hobby to make money and don’t know where to start, choose one that you are really into. What are some skills you good at that nobody else does? You want to combine your joy with something that other people are unaware of. This will give you find a good start.

Quick And Helpful Tips For HobbiesHorseback riding is an excellent hobby if you to enjoy time spent in nature. You can also bond with your horse as well.

Have a lot of different hobbies.Having diverse interests will make you a more diverse.It may be smart to choose hobbies that can be done at various times and seasons of the year or day.

Calligraphy can spice up your life if you choose it as a fun and fancy hobby. You could enroll in calligraphy You will like being able to do something with your own handwriting improves as you practice.

If you are an avid traveler, you could start a collection for souvenirs you get at your destinations after you finish your trips. You might choose to collect items like spoons, pottery, or unique postcards. No matter what you choose to collect, the collection will have a sentimental value that will bring back memories for years to come.

Golf is known to be a favorite hobby for many, but it costs a bunch to be able to play on a consistent basis. Deep sea fishing and car collecting are other hobbies that cost money. These hobbies that cost a lot of money. Know what you can afford to spend and make your hobby.

Star gazing can be a fun hobby.Star gazing is amazing because you to discover new ways of looking at the night sky. It endows you a little more. You simply need an unlit area and a telescope to see everything.

Keep the area where you enjoy your hobby activities neat and tidy. This makes sure that you will know where everything you’re looking for. You will also be safer area to work with.You never want an injury to occur because things were in disarray.

Find a friend or co-worker who enjoys the same hobby as you, regularly. Even if you only do it once or twice every month, this helps you make time to enjoy your hobby. It also helps you to bond with others that have the same types of interests as you.

Carefully read the directions to see what items you are using. Keep hobby organized and be sure you clean it after each session. You might even consider learning from someone that you can learn the hobby. Your hobby is going to be enjoyable for a lot of years if you always practice safety first.

Research a hobby before starting it. Not every hobby is the same for you. There are a lot which require creativity, others that allow activity, or they can take up a lot of your time.

If you enjoy jigsaw puzzles and don’t want to tie up a table in your house, get a puzzle board. It is a great way to keep the puzzle in use. The board will keep all of the various pieces secure until next time.

There are blogs for different reasons. You may find new friends and possibly earn some money if you apply good SEO practices to your blog.

You can create cakes to show off to your family and friends. There is all sort of places that you can take classes, or you can just go to your hobby store and buy a decorating set with an instruction video.Tips For Hobbies

Don’t get into a hobby that needs a lot of money to get started. You never want to spend a lot of money only to realize you don’t enjoy the hobby.

A wonderful hobby is doll collecting. You can get dolls from every country in the world.

Reading is a terrific hobby for any child to enjoy. The best way to do that is reading is to read to them beginning at a young age. People who love to read can go farther in education than those who have difficulty reading.

This is a hobby for young and old. Learn the basics and then move up to writing your own. You can also just prefer to learn the songs you like so you can play them to people you know.

Do you like space? Make astronomy as your hobby! You can learn a lot from sky watching. A telescope can mean a brand new world. This is a great hobby is especially enjoyable when you share it with your kids.

A hobby can benefit both you and the world. Use what you learned here to have a great time with your hobby. Hobbies can be fun – go enjoy yourself!